What to Record
For every trade, log: date and time, instrument, direction (long/short), entry price, stop-loss, take-profit, position size, outcome (P&L), and — critically — why you took the trade and how you felt.
The 'why' and 'how you felt' columns are the most valuable. They reveal patterns that raw numbers can't: you might discover that your Monday trades consistently lose, or that trades taken after a loss are 40% less profitable, or that you perform best on GBP/USD and worst on exotic pairs.
How to Review
Set aside time weekly or monthly to review your journal. Look for patterns:
- Which setups are most profitable? Focus on them.
- Which instruments do you trade best? Specialise.
- When do you make your worst decisions? Avoid those conditions.
- Are you following your trading plan? If not, why not?
This review process is how professional traders improve. It's not glamorous, but it works better than any indicator, signal service, or trading course.
Formats That Work
A spreadsheet is fine. A notebook is fine. A dedicated journaling app is fine. The format doesn't matter — consistency does. The best journal is the one you actually use after every trade, not the beautifully designed template you filled in for three days and abandoned.
Start simple: date, instrument, direction, entry, exit, P&L, notes. Add columns as you discover what data is most useful for your style.
The Compound Effect
The improvements from journaling are incremental but they compound. A 1% improvement in win rate, a slightly better average risk-to-reward ratio, one fewer emotional trade per week — these small gains, accumulated over months, transform your results. The journal is the mechanism that makes this possible.
Key Takeaways
- Record every trade: entry, exit, P&L, reasoning, and emotional state
- The 'why' and 'how you felt' columns reveal the most valuable patterns
- Review weekly or monthly — look for patterns in winners, losers, and behaviour
- The format doesn't matter — consistency does
- Small improvements from journaling compound into significant performance gains